Does Basin Shape Reflect Stage of Landscape Evolution?

The ever-evolving topography of the Earth has always sparked human curiosity. Imagine the astonishment of the first person who found a seashell atop a mountain, proof that the Earth's surface was not static but had a story to tell.

In 1795, James Hutton proposed a revolutionary idea: the Earth is far older than anyone had imagined, and its landscapes are the result of slow, continuous processes acting over immense spans of time. Later, in 1830, Charles Lyell expanded on Hutton’s vision in his book Principles of Geology, suggesting that landscapes evolve through gradual, incremental changes that shape mountains, valleys, and rivers over billions of years.

This understanding didn’t just reshape geology, it influenced Charles Darwin, who carried Lyell’s book aboard the Beagle. The concept of gradual evolution of earth helped Darwin frame his revolutionary theory of biological evolution in The Origin of Species (1859). Together, these ideas highlight: studying how landscapes evolve helps us uncover the mysteries of nature, echoing the words often attributed to Leonardo da Vinci: “Learn from nature, for there lies the future.”

The Rivers That Remember

Rivers are the skeletons of landscapes, preserve signatures of evolution. Like, the branching, tree-like structure of a river network reflects the efficiency with which water and sediment are transported across the terrain.

To achieve this efficiency, river systems evolve toward configurations that minimize energy expenditure, the energy required to move water and sediment downslope. This principle is formalized in the Optimal Channel Network (OCN) theory, which proposes that drainage networks evolve toward a state that minimizes total energy use.

Building on this idea, our study proposed a new metric, ∆E (relative energy expenditure), which measures how efficiently a landscape expends energy relative to its optimal configuration. A higher ∆E indicates that the landscape is less efficient and therefore younger in its stage of evolution.




If energy efficiency evolves with time, could the shape of a basin also reveal its stage of evolution?

River networks evolve through dynamic processes like stream capture and divide migration, constantly reorganizing themselves. These processes can be quantified using morphometric indices, numerical descriptors of landscape form. One of the most widely used relationships is Hack’s Law, which links the main channel length (L) to the drainage area (A) through a scaling relationship:

Here, the Hack’s exponent (h) captures key aspects of basin morphology. Several studies suggest that h evolves with landscape development.

In our study of 25 islands, we found a strong, positive relationship between Hack’s exponent (h) and ∆E. Both metrics increased together, and numerical simulations further confirmed that they rise systematically with time. One of the most fascinating cases is found in the Hawaiian Islands. As these volcanic islands age, both h and ∆E increase, suggesting that these metrics capture the temporal trajectory of landscape maturity. In essence, the morphology of a river basin and the energy it expends are intertwined, together revealing the evolutionary stage of the landscape. Understanding how landscapes evolve is not just about tracing the past, it’s about predicting the future. As climate and tectonic forces continue to reshape the Earth’s surface, metrics like ∆E and h offer a window into the processes that govern erosion, river organization, and landscape resilience. By learning from the rivers and the stories they carve, we continue to read the Earth’s history written in its stones and streams.

 

Author: Saba Shakeel Raina
PhD Research Scholar, IIT Bombay
Article: “On Hack’s Law and Efficiency of Landscapes,” published in Earth Surface Processes and Landforms (2025), http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/esp.70207


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

GROW-N: A Small Attempt to Fill a Big Gap

What (Not) To Do as an Early Career Researcher and Academic in India

The Pleasure of Being an Academic: A Journey with Prof. B.S. Murty